Pampers Pure vs Honest Diapers Review (With Test Video)

In this Pampers Pure vs Honest diapers review, you will get to:

and more.

Let’s get started

I hope you’ll love the products we recommend! Just a quick note: if you click on a product link below and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

Pampers Pure vs Honest: Quick Comparison Table


Mixed reviews

Feels Rough


Somewhat Expensive

Pricier Than Pampers Pure


Mixed reviews

Mixed reviews


Adequately Flexible

Runs Small

Wetness Indicator



Below is a detailed info about Honest vs Pampers Pure diapers

Differences Between Honest vs Pampers Pure


I’ve noticed that Pampers Pure is larger than Honest, especially at the back.

Pampers Pure in general, is slightly wider and longer than Honest.

But here’s the thing – I noticed Honest has a longer absorbency core than Pampers Pure.

That means, Honest can better absorb wetness at the front and back, since it actually has an absorbent core at both ends, unlike Pampers Pure.

Both diapers have the same available sizes, starting at Newborn size up to Size 7. 


I find Pampers Pure less rough than Honest. 

Pampers Pure feels adequately soft, but not as cottony soft as say, Hello Bello.

(I have a Hello Bello vs Pampers Pure comparison review here if you’re interested!)

Anyway, I’ve seen some mixed comments from other parents saying that Pampers Pure doesn’t feel as soft and even caused a diaper rash. While others say it’s the only diaper that didn’t irritate their baby’s sensitive skin.

With regards to Honest, I seriously found it off-putting that it looked like a sanitary napkin.

Like seriously, am I the only one who’s turned off by how it looks like? 

pampers pure vs honest diapers liner
Seriously, look at Honest diaper’s “sanitary napkin” liner look?!

Cause I find sanitary napkins not that soft and now I already have this instant bias against Honest.

I haven’t seen anyone commenting yet on how it looks like a sanitary napkin – no mention of it in forums, Facebook groups, or even on Reddit. 

So I’m thinking, am I the only crazy bitch here, lol.

And now that I have that biased thinking, I really don’t like how Honest feels.

It feels rougher than Pampers Pure, at least for me.

I’ve also read a lot of mixed reviews about Honest’s “gentleness” on baby’s skin, with some saying it feels soft and comfy on their kid.

While others say it irritated their baby’s skin.


This is a little bit tricky to assess since both diapers, based on my test, are not very efficient in absorbing a lot of wetness.

It was unlike my comparison review of Huggies Little Snugglers vs Hello Bello – you can clearly see who won the absorbency test there!

Anyway, I did consider a winner between Honest vs Pampers Pure when it comes to absorbency, which you can watch in my comparison video review below, at the 2:40 mark:

If you don’t have time to watch the 2 absorbency tests I did, it was Honest Diaper that won both tests.

But you have to watch the whole video to see why I don’t give both diapers high marks for absorption.

I’ve also seen mixed reviews for both diapers regarding their absorbency. With some parents saying it prevents diaper leaks, while others are saying it has caused a lot of diaper blowouts.

Security and Fit

Both Pampers Pure and Honest have decent flexibility but are not super stretchable, based on my test.

But for most parents, they find Pampers Pure adequately flexible and Honest seems to run small and fits skinny babies best.

They have more or less the same kind of stretchiness, especially at the leg-hole part.

But Honest has stickier tabs than Pampers Pure.

Pampers Pure and Honest diapers tabs

Sticky tabs are necessary to keep the diapers on a very curious, very active baby, especially when the diaper is filled with poop and pee!


Hello Bello wins this round at least, as it offers more colorful prints and designs, than Pampers Pure.

Colorful diapers can help distract a baby during a diaper change.

I just really wished both diapers had the “front” and “back” label, so parents can easily tell which side is which, making changing diapers much more quicker.

Pampers pure and honest diapers front
Here’s the font of Pampers Pure and Honest diapers
Honest diapers and Pampers pure diapers back
And here’s the back

Similarities: Honest Diapers vs Pampers Pure

Wetness Indicator 

Both have a wetness indicator although I can barely see Honest’s, probably because of the diaper design that I picked for testing.


Both Pampers Pure and Honest don’t come cheap. Honest actually is more expensive than Pampers Pure.

They’re not super expensive like Coterie diapers, but they’re still pricey.

I would recommend neither for those with a tight budget.

Pros and Cons: Pampers Pure Diapers vs Honest Diapers

Pampers Pure

Pros of Pampers Pure Diapers

  • Softer than Honest
  • Larger and wider than Honest

Cons of Pampers Pure Diapers

  • Mixed reviews on absorption
  • Somewhat expensive
honest diapers

Honest Diapers

Pros of Honest Diapers

  • Absorbs slightly better than Pampers Pure
  • Stickier tab than Pampers Pure

Cons of Honest Diapers

  • Feels rougher than Pampers Pure
  • More expensive than Pampers Pure

Diapering Tips and Hacks

Pampers Pure

honest diapers

Honest Diapers

FAQ: Honest Diapers vs Pampers Pure

Is Honest better than Pampers?

Yes, Honest is better than Pampers Pure when it comes to absorption. Watch again my absorbency test video above for further proof

Why is Pampers Pure better?

Pampers Pure is better than Honest diapers when it comes to softness and size coverage at the back – its back is wider than Honest diapers.

What is the difference between Pampers and Pampers Pure?

The difference between Pampers Pure and Pampers Swaddlers is that Pampers Swaddlers have a way better absorption.
While Pampers Pure is marketed as a gentler diaper, made with soft plant-based ingredients.

What is so special about Honest diapers?

The special thing about Honest diapers is that it has marketed itself as a non-toxic diaper that has a decent absorption rate, as most non-toxic diapers have sucky absorbency.

Alternatives to Pampers Pure vs Honest

Check out other diaper options below, that arguably, might be better than Honest diapers or Pampers Pure:

Pampers Pure vs Honest: Which One Should You Pick?

If you only want to choose between Pampers Pure vs Honest and your priority is the diaper’s absorption, I’d say go for Honest diapers.

But if you want a gentler diaper, I’d recommend Pampers Pure.

I’d highly recommend though to test out both diapers as you might have a different experience with it.

Get a small pack first and see which one works better for your baby.

Pampers Pure

honest diapers

Honest Diapers

I hope this article has been helpful.

If you like this one, check out my guides on: