Crib Sheets Buying Guide (For New Overwhelmed Parents)

You’d think it was so simple to buy crib sheets but think again. With so many choices and options nowadays, it’s actually pretty darn challenging! Especially for new parents. 

Enter our crib sheets buying guide – an essential in helping you choose the right and safe crib sheets.

In this article, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know about crib sheets:

  • which material is best for what skin, weather, etc.
  • Why choose fitted crib sheets over flat crib sheets
  • How to use and care for your crib sheets
  • highly recommended crib sheets by parents
  • and more!

Let’s start with the factors in choosing the best crib sheets.

Disclosure: I hope you’ll love the products we recommend! Just a quick note: If you click on a product link below and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.

How To Choose the Best Crib Sheets

Fabric Material

If you want to know the best crib sheet material there is, cotton is always a classic and popular choice. 

You can never go wrong with choosing cotton fabrics for crib sheets. 

But if you’re curious to know how other fabric materials fare and you want to explore their pros and cons as a crib sheet, check them out below:

Pure Cotton

  • Pros: Classic, popular choice, comfortable, breathable, and widely available
  • Cons: If not well cared for, may wrinkle easily and can shrink after washing

Bamboo & Cotton

  • Pros: Soft, eco-friendly, moisture-wicking, and hypoallergenic
  • Cons: Can be more expensive than other options

Organic Cotton

  • Pros: Hypoallergenic, chemical-free, and safe for sensitive skin 
  • Cons: Generally more expensive, and color choices may be limited.

Jersey Knit

  • Pros: Stretchy, cozy, and feels like a favorite T-shirt
  • Cons: If not well taken care of, can wear out quicker than other materials.


  • Pros: Lightweight and breathable, ideal for warm weather
  • Cons: Can be less durable over time, might bunch up and become a safety issue for newborns


  • Pros: Breathable, lightweight, and suitable for hot climates
  • Cons: Can be prone to wrinkles and may require more care

Polyester Blend

  • Pros: Wrinkle-resistant and durable
  • Cons: May not be as breathable as natural fibers


  • Pros: Easy to care for and budget-friendly
  • Cons: May not provide as much breathability as natural fibers.


  • Pros: Insulating and soft, perfect for colder months
  • Cons: Can be too warm for warmer seasons

Snug Fit and Safety

When purchasing crib sheets, ensure they have a snug fit on the mattress. 

Opt for fitted sheets designed specifically for cribs. 

A proper fit prevents the sheet from coming loose, reducing the risk of suffocation hazards.

Related Article: Safe Sleep for Babies

Mattress Depth and Shrinking

Check the crib mattress dimensions before buying sheets to ensure a proper fit. Get one that can accommodate a standard crib thickness of 6 inches.

You’d want something with enough fabric that you don’t need to pull and tug too much to fit the sheet in the crib, everytime you need to change it.

Keep in mind that some sheets might shrink after washing.

Durability and Certifications

Look for crib sheets that are well-made and durable to withstand multiple washes. 

Additionally, consider sheets with safety certifications, such as OEKO-TEX or GOTS, which ensure they are free from harmful chemicals.

Design and Price

While aesthetics matter, prioritize comfort and safety over design. 

There’s a wide range of designs to choose from, so you can find something that matches your nursery theme. 

Related Article: Crib Placement and Nursery Layout Ideas

Price varies based on material and brand, so set a budget and explore options within that range. 


Don’t forget to check the manufacturer’s crib sheet size chart to ensure the right fit for your crib. Some might vary, depending on the brand and shape of the crib.

Crib Sheet Sizes

Crib sheets come in various sizes to fit different cribs and sleep spaces:

  • Standard Crib Sheet Size: Fits standard crib mattresses, usually around 52″ x 28″.
  • Mini Crib Sheet Size: Designed for mini cribs with mattresses around 38″ x 24″.
  • Specialty Crib Sheet Size: Some cribs have unique mattress dimensions, so be sure to measure and buy accordingly.

Why Size Matters

  • Safety and Comfort

Choosing the right size crib sheet is crucial for your baby’s safety and comfort. 

Sheets that are too loose can pose a suffocation hazard, while those that are too tight might not stay put, disrupting your baby’s sleep.

Related Article: Shush Pat Method: Make Your Baby Sleep With This Technique!

  • Aesthetics

A well-fitting crib sheet also enhances the overall aesthetics of the nursery. A snugly fitted sheet gives the crib a neat and inviting appearance.

Other Considerations for Crib Sheets

Thread Count, Weave, and Thickness

Higher thread counts generally indicate softer sheets, but other factors like weave and thickness also contribute to comfort. 

A thread count of at least 200 should suffice for a comfortable and durable choice.

Crib Sheets: Flat Versus Fitted

If you can’t decide between flat or fitted sheets, go for the latter, because of the following reasons: 

  • Safety

Flat sheets need to be tucked in tightly and need to stay that way. And if you have a baby that’s always moving in their crib even while sleeping, that can be downright impossible.

Fitted sheets stay securely in place, reducing the risk of entanglement. 

  • Ease of Use

Fitted sheets are easier to put on and remove, saving you time and effort, compared to flat sheets.

  • Neat Appearance

Fitted sheets provide a smooth and tidy look to the crib, enhancing the overall aesthetic of the nursery.

Crib Sheet Care Tips

Proper care ensures the longevity and hygiene of your crib sheets:

  • Washing

Follow care instructions and use a gentle, baby-safe detergent. Wash crib sheets separately to prevent pilling.

  • Drying

Line drying or using a low heat setting in the dryer helps maintain the fabric’s quality.

  • Non-Toxic Cleaning Products

If you need to spot-clean, use non-toxic, baby-safe cleaning products (such as below) to avoid any skin irritation:

Best Crib Sheets

Here are two of the most popular, best crib sheets that are highly recommended by experts and tons of parents.

Burt’s Bees Baby Fitted Crib Sheet

HonestBaby Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet

Check out more of the best crib sheets here.

Using Crib Sheets (Quick Guide)

How Many Crib Sheets Should I Buy?

I would highly recommend having a minimum of 2 sheets and a maximum of 4 sheets. 

You will need some extra sheets for quick changes, especially when dealing with nighttime diaper leaks and diaper blowouts.

How Tight Should Crib Sheets Fit?

Sheets should fit snugly but not be overly tight, that it might suddenly pop off, which can be a safety hazard for your baby. They should, at best, fit a standard crib mattress that’s 6 inches thick.

How Often Should You Change Baby Crib Sheets?

Baby crib sheets should be changed at least once a week or more often if needed. Babies can get messy with their drool, spit, diaper poonamis and more, so take note to regularly change their crib sheets.

How Should I Wash and Care For My Baby’s Crib Sheets?: 

The best way to care for baby crib sheets is to read the manufacturer’s care instructions and use gentle, baby-friendly detergent.

How Do I Know My Baby Is Having A Skin Reaction To A Certain Fabric?

Watch for signs of redness, irritation, or rashes on your baby’s skin.

Related Article: Diaper Rash (Treatments, Types, Causes, and Prevention)

FAQ: Crib Sheets Buying Guide

What to Look for When Buying a Crib Sheet?

When looking for crib sheets, consider their material, fit, safety certifications, design, and price.

Do Crib Sheets Fit All Cribs?

No, not all crib sheets fit all cribs. 
Some come in different sizes, so it’s essential to check the dimensions of your crib mattress and buy sheets that match.

How Many Sheets Should You Have for a Baby Crib?

It’s recommended to have at least 2-4 crib sheets, in case of diaper accidents and emergencies.

How Do I Choose Crib Bedding?

When choosing crib bedding, material quality, size, durability, price, and design. 

What Size Crib Sheets Do I Need?

The size of crib sheets depends on your crib’s mattress dimensions. Standard, mini, and specialty sizes are available.

What Is the Most Breathable Fabric for Crib Sheets?

The most breathable fabrics for fabric sheets are natural materials like cotton, bamboo, and muslin.

How Much Should Crib Sheets Cost?

Crib sheet costs can vary based on material and brand, but you can find quality options in a range of budgets.

Do I Need Organic Crib Sheets?

No, you don’t need organic crib sheets. They are an ideal choice, especially for babies with sensitive skin or allergies but they’re not newborn essentials.

Crib Safety (Quick Guide)

Ensure your baby’s safety by following these crib safety guidelines:

  • Use a firm crib mattress that fits snugly.
  • Avoid loose bedding, pillows, or toys in the crib.
  • Place your baby on their back to sleep.
  • Keep the crib away from cords or window blinds.

Crib Sheets Buying Guide: Takeaway

Choosing the right crib sheets is an essential part of creating a cozy and safe sleep environment for your baby. 

By considering materials, sizes, and care tips, you can make an informed decision that prioritizes your baby’s comfort and peace of mind. 

I hope this crib sheets buying guide has been helpful. 

If you found this article helpful, be sure to check out Best Non Toxic Cribs (Greenguard Certified Cribs!), Best Affordable Baby Cribs (Under $200!), and Best Baby Cribs for Newborns and Toddlers.