Pull Ups vs Easy Ups: Toilet Training Pants Showdown! [Comparison Review]

Thinking of potty training your toddler? Then you might have heard of Huggies Pull Ups vs Easy Ups and want to compare them. 

In this article, I’ve researched their similar features and what makes them different from one another, as well as their pros and cons.

I’ve also included a lot of feedback and advice from real parents online about using either the Pulls Ups or Easy Ups.

I’ve also added some tips on using them if leakages keep happening.

There’s also a list of training diaper alternatives that you might want to explore if you’re still on the fence between these 2 toilet training pants.

Let’s start with a quick feature comparison between Pull Ups vs Easy Ups.

(Some of the links in this post may be affiliate links. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. All opinions remain my own. For more information see Affiliate Disclosure Policy.)

In a hurry? We recommend..

Use Huggies Pull Ups for daytime, for its convenient resealable sides and a sort of wetness indicator.

But for a more comfortable diaper, our vote goes to Pampers Easy Ups.

Huggies Pull-Ups Girls’ Potty Training Pants 

Huggies Pull-Ups Boys’ Potty Training Pants 


Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants Boys and Girls 

Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants Girls and Boys

Pull Ups vs Easy Ups Feature Comparison Table

This is best viewed on a desktop. Here’s a quick feature comparison guide of Pull Ups vs Easy Ups

FeaturesPull-UpsEasy Ups
Size2T–3T (18-34 lbs.), 3T–4T (32-40 lbs.), 4T–5T (38+ lbs.)2T–3T (16–34 lb), 3T–4T (30–40 lb), 4T–5T (37+ lb), 5T–6T (41+ lb)
Types• Pull-Ups Potty training pants
• Pull-Ups Night Time training pants
• Pull-Ups New Leaf training underwear
Just one
ComfortMixed reviewsSoft and comfortable
ConvenienceWith refastenable sidesWith easy to tear sides
AbsorbencyMixed reviewsVery absorbent
Wetness IndicatorAvailableNot available
Design• Mickey Mouse and Minnie Mouse• PJ Mask and Trolls
• Also comes with limited edition designs
PriceCheaper than Pampers Easy UpsMore expensive

Below is more detailed info on Easy Ups vs Pull Ups.

Pampers Pull Ups vs Easy Ups: Similarities

Reputable Brand

Both are manufactured by well-known companies that are also makers of various popular baby products.

Pampers were introduced in 1961 and are made by Procter and Gamble.

Their diapers are paraben, latex, and chlorine-free, making them safe for your little ones’ skin.

You can read the rest of the ingredients and more info about Pampers Easy Ups here.

Huggies came from Kimberly-Clark and were introduced in the market by 1968.

Huggies pull ups are also hypoallergenic diapers, just like their Swaddlers, Little Snugglers, and other Huggies diapers. 

All are free from lotion, paraben, natural rubber latex, and other harsh ingredients that can harm your child’s skin.

Check out more info on their diaper ingredients here.

And that’s it, that’s only the major similar trait between Pulls Ups and Easy Ups! The rest are a little and a whole lot different, read them below.

Huggies Pull-Ups Girls’ Potty Training Pants 

Huggies Pull-Ups Boys’ Potty Training Pants 


Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants Boys and Girls 

Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants Girls and Boys

Difference Between Huggies Easy Ups vs Pull Ups

Sizes 

Pampers Easy Ups are available in sizes 2T-3T, 3T-4T, 4T-5T and 5T-6T.

While Huggies Pull-Ups size starts at 2T up to 5T.

It can be a little bit confusing as to what size to get for your child, with manufacturers advising to follow the recommended weight instead of clothing size.

So prepare for a bit of trial and error, especially if you’ve never tried both training pants.

Most parents are saying to always go one size up for both the Easy Ups and Pull-Ups diapers.

Types

It’s pretty straightforward with Pampers as they only have 1 kind of training pants diaper – the Easy Ups.

It’s quite different with Huggies, as they have 3 types of Pull Ups! 

Huggies has:

I think I’ll have to do another article to compare the 3 different types of Huggies Pull-Ups.

But for now, let’s just focus on the Huggies Pull-Ups Potty training pants.

Huggies Pull-Ups Girls’ Potty Training Pants 

Huggies Pull-Ups Boys’ Potty Training Pants 

Comfort 

Both the Pull-ups vs Easy Ups are like a training diaper-underwear. 

It’s designed to make it easy for toddlers to push down and pull up their diapers on their own.

Which can encourage them to become more independent and boost up their confidence when potty training!

Pampers Easy Ups have a super soft like cotton quality, a trait that has always been in their diapers, even in their Swaddlers.

A lot of parents say it looks very comfortable on their kid, it’s a whole lot stretchier and flexible, especially the waistband area.

The sides are mesh and very soft and don’t feel rough or scratchy on your toddler’s skin.

A few parents though have complained about their kids having rashes or discomfort from wearing Pampers Easy Ups.

Some parents have also noticed a strong powdery smell coming from the Easy Ups, especially when it gets wet.

Huggies Pull-Ups are also made of soft material with an elastic and stretchy waistband.

But a lot of parents are saying it’s not as comfortable as Pampers, especially the sides. 

Their toddlers have been complaining about Huggies Pull Ups, saying that it feels scratchy, irritating their skin, and leaving red marks and rashes.

Convenience

A lot of parents and even daycare teachers prefer Huggies Pull Ups because of its very convenient feature – the refastenable sides.

With Huggies, you don’t need to take off your kid’s underwear and pants to remove or put back on the diaper, because of its refastenable feature.

Pampers don’t have that feature but you can easily rip off the sides if you need to. Especially when you have a very spoiled and poopy diaper.

For most parents and caregivers though, the lack of a velcro tab or refastenable sides can be a big inconvenience, especially in a public place.

Because to take off the Pampers Easy Ups and put it back on, you must take off your child’s pants and shoes.

Which I can imagine is quite a hassle in public, especially for a very independent and assertive child, who wants to take off their diapers on their own.

Absorbency 

Pampers Easy Ups has dual leak guard barriers and extra absorbent channels that can protect against diaper leakages.

Most parents are happy with how absorbent Pampers Easy Ups is, especially with their very active kids. As it can hold messes for hours.

Some parents have even managed it for overnight use with zero to minimal diaper change!

A few parents though have complained about how leaky it can get, especially when used for naps or nighttime sleeping.

Huggies Pull ups have also an extra absorbency and leak protection feature where it counts, especially at the sides.

It has a lot of mixed reviews though with some parents saying that it can hold plenty of liquid and doesn’t leak even at night.

While some have complained that it’s not absorbing at all, and would leak for less than 2 hours.

Other parents said that it does a decent job of absorbing wetness. It still does leak sometimes but not a big deal-breaker for them as they’re training their kids out of diapers.

Wetness indicator

Pampers Easy Ups doesn’t have any sort of wetness indicator. While with Huggies Pull Ups, you can tell it’s wet when its Disney graphics are fading away.

Which personally, I don’t think it’s much of a big deal if you’re using this to toilet train your little one.

Potty training includes teaching toddlers to be aware that they need to go and to tell you that.

So there’s really no need for the wetness indicator feature.

But if you’re using these types of diapers for your very uncooperative kid who hates diaper changing or just can’t stay still, then that’s a different matter. Just take note that Pampers doesn’t have the wetness indicator.

Design 

Both have very popular cartoon characters that are a hit for toddlers!

Pampers Easy Ups has the PJ Mask for boys and Trolls for girls. 

Although some parents have noted that they’re missing the Owlette character, which can be unfortunate especially if your kids are big fans of PJ Mask.

Easy Ups also has some limited edition designs. As of this publishing, they’re currently selling Space Jam limited edition designs.

Huggies Pull Ups has Mickey Mouse for boys and Minnie Mouse for girls.

Price

Both Pull Ups vs Easy Ups have reasonable prices and some parents mentioned it’s a lot cheaper to buy it online than get it at physical stores

Huggies Pull Ups is cheaper though compared to Pampers Easy Ups.

You can save more on both training pants with Amazon’s Subscribe & Save, which gives you 15% OFF.

Easy Ups vs Pull Ups: Pros and Cons

Here’s a general overview of the advantages and drawbacks of the Pull Ups vs Easy Ups

Huggies Pull Ups

Huggies Pull-Ups Girls’ Potty Training Pants 

Huggies Pull-Ups Boys’ Potty Training Pants 

Pros

  • Cheaper than Pampers Easy Ups
  • Has resealable sides and wetness indicator

Cons

  • Has complains of feeling scratchy on the sides
  • Has mixed reviews on absorbency

Pampers Easy Ups 

Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants Boys and Girls 

Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants Girls and Boys

Pros

  • Soft and very comfortable
  • Very absorbent

Cons

  • Has complains of leaking sometimes
  • Pricier than Huggies Pull Ups

Alternatives to Huggies Pull Ups vs Pampers Easy Ups

If you’d like to explore other training pants options, here are a few that are recommended by parents online:

Goodnites Nighttime Bedwetting Underwear

Pampers Pull On Cruisers 360° Fit


Pull-Ups New Leaf Girls’ Potty Training Pants Training Underwear

Pampers Pull On Cruisers 3MooMoo Baby 8 Packs Toddler Training Underwear


Peejamas

pull ups vs easy ups

Tips and Tricks for Using Easy Ups or Pull Ups

Use a waterproof pad protector

These have been lifesavers. I thought I was going insane from changing the bedsheet every day!

There was even a time where I just placed a towel on the bed and just made my daughter move on the dry side of the bed, cause I was too effing tired (and lazy) to change it! 

So waterproof mattress pad protectors are the bomb. Especially those that can stay in place and are comfortable to lie on for your kids.

YIVEKO Baby Waterproof Bed Pad

Waterproof Bed Mat Pee Pads for Kids

• Use diaper inserts at night

If you have a heavy wetter, especially at night, use a diaper insert. It will absorb more of the wetness, which means you get to change the sheets less.

Sposie Overnight

• Use a diaper insert + cloth diaper cover

Try using both combinations if diaper leakages and blowouts are the banes of your existence.

wegreeco Washable Reusable Baby Cloth Pocket 

Pampers Easy Ups vs Huggies Pull Ups: FAQ

Are Easy Ups the same as Pull-Ups?

Yes, they both are intended for potty training and are easy to take off and pull up for a toddler. 

But they do have a lot of differences, for eg., Huggies Pull Ups has a sort of wetness indicator and has a resealable side. 

While Pampers doesn’t have either but most parents said Pamper’s Easy Ups are softer and more comfortable than Huggies Pull Ups.

Are diapers better than pull-ups?

They can be if your kid is older, more mobile and they can’t keep still so you can easily change their diaper.

When it comes to absorbency and overnight use, most parents noticed that it only does a decent job at keeping away leakages, making diapers better at absorbing wetness.

Can I use Easy Ups for nighttime protection?

Yes. Of course it all depends on the kid but a lot of parents have used it as an overnight diaper and have been very happy with its absorbency. 

Can you reuse a dry Pull-Up?

Yes but only up to a certain point, as the material can get worn out and it’s not hygienic for your little ones, as they might develop diaper rashes.

Pull Ups vs Easy Ups: Which One Should You Get?

Based on my research and the hundreds of reviews and feedback from parents online, I’d recommend Huggies Pull Ups for daytime use and if there’s zero to minimal leakages, for nighttime use too.

Huggies Pull-Ups Girls’ Potty Training Pants 

Huggies Pull-Ups Boys’ Potty Training Pants 

But if it keeps leaking at night, I’d recommend using Pampers Easy Ups for overnight sleeping but still use Huggies Pull Ups for daytime.

Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants Boys and Girls 

Pampers Easy Ups Training Pants Girls and Boys

A lot of parents, caregivers, and even daycare teachers prefer Huggies Pull Ups for their resealable sides. Some teachers will even ask you to use Huggies Pull Ups for school!

The resealable feature is convenient to have, as kids don’t need to remove their clothing when putting on and taking off their diapers.

Personally, though, I have never used any training pants or diapers on my kid. 

I’ll write more on how I potty trained my kid next time. But for me, I just did it the traditional way. 

We had regular toilet visits, no wearing of diapers (even at night). We also used waterproof pad protectors until she had completely stopped peeing at night in her undies.

It was challenging at first and it took a month for my kid to confidently use the toilet and to have ZERO accidents at night.

But if you’d be more comfortable with using a training pants diaper, by all means, use one. I almost lost my marbles toilet training my kid without some training pants, so please for your sanity, get one.

And also don’t put too much pressure on yourself and your kid. 

If they’re growing normally, they will eventually be potty trained. You guys can do this!

Anyway, I hope this article has helped you finally decide between Pampers Pull Ups vs Easy Ups.