If you’re looking for a quick answer to which is better – Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby – the Ergobaby is the better carrier. Read up on their differences, similarities, and why the Ergobaby is a better choice.
It’s quite overwhelming to choose and go through dozens of baby carriers online. But if you have settled on the Ergobaby 360 All-Position and the BabyBjörn One Air Mesh baby carrier, then this article will help you finally make a decision.
I’ve researched their features, identifying their differences and similarities. I even looked up some instruction videos on how to use them, so you can really gauge which is the better or more suitable carrier for you.
Both are excellent carriers though and both have their own strengths (and weaknesses).
Let’s dive in first on Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby’s similarities.
List of Contents
Baby Bjorn Vs Ergobaby: Similarities
Fit For All
Just make sure to adjust the straps accordingly to make both baby carriers a comfortable fit.
Both are breathable mesh baby carriers, which is great for wearing during the warm weather or when going out for hikes, or any other summer adventures.
The Baby Bjorn has an airy 3D mesh material that is soft and flexible. You don’t even need to wash it when you get it out of the box! (Although, it’s probably better if you do).
The material is pleasant and comfortable enough for your baby’s gentle skin and flexible enough that it retains its shape, wash after wash.
The Ergobaby has also a soft and durable mesh design that’s lightweight and breathable for your baby. It’s sturdy too, so you don’t need to worry about any snagging or ripping.
It can work great for winter too! Just make sure that your baby is all bundled up.
Both are also “hip-friendly” baby carriers, as certified by the International Hip Dysplasia Institute.
This means that both the Bab Bjorn and Ergo gives the correct support to your baby’s hips and encourages good hip joint development, which is especially important during the first months of life.
Ease of Use
All baby carriers have a learning curve so how easy is it to use is really subjective.
For the Ergobaby 360, once you’ve gotten used to it, it’s relatively easy to put it on and off, with your baby, by yourself.
I might be biased because I used to have an Ergo carrier (Omni not 360) but I did find it pretty easy to use, without any help.
Putting in newborns though, with the infant insert might be a bit tricky.
Especially if you lost your infant insert and you need an alternative to it, like a blanket or towel.
There are also some mixed reviews about its buckles. Some find it hard to buckle it at the back on their own and need some help, while others have an easier time doing it.
Some find Ergo more comfortable to use than the Baby Bjorn, especially when their baby gets bigger/ heavier.
Which is understandable, considering that Ergo can be used until your kid is 45 lbs while the Bjorn is only until 33 lbs.
Check out the video on the Ergo’s page on how to use it with the infant insert:
You can see how big the infant insert so that would be a little bit tricky to put on, especially for new parents.
(By the way, if you want to watch the videos really quickly, you can just adjust the playback speed by clicking on the settings or gear icon on the video.
Here’s some neat tricks on the Ergo 360, just in case you missed them from the instruction manual or videos:
This is how you switch from facing in to facing out position
This is the latest video that I can find, that shows how to switch from facing in and facing out position
Now on to Baby Bjorn.
The Baby Bjorn has mixed reviews on its ease of use as well.
Some find it comfortable and they love how quick and quick and convenient it is to get a baby in and out of it.
Check out how to use the Baby Bjorn on this video:
Others find it hard to work and adjust the buckles.
You can skip the commentary below but I just need to share this.
For both brands, I just find it a little bit frustrating to look for an UPDATED video on their website or on their youtube channel that tells me exactly how to use their baby carrier.
Most of the videos online are 3 years old or older. I know that those videos are still useful and the tips there are still applicable but still, it would have been nice it they can update the videos. Especially when there’s an updated version of their baby carriers.
But anyway, at least there’s still some other videos available for that.
But I kinda really wish the Ergo and Baby Bjorn team do updated instructional videos, just to make things easier and clearer for the consumer.
Not everything is clearly written in instruction manuals. And for most people, it’s much better to understand how to use a product and such, when watching it from a video.
K, rant over.
Both baby carriers have an adjustable seat to accommodate your growing baby but they differ in how to adjust it.
The Baby Bjorn comes with 2 height setting zippers on the inside of the carrier.
You can use the newborn setting until your child is about 4 months old then lower the zipper to the baby/toddler position for children ages 4-36 months (about 24-40 inches).
The Ergo 360 though, has to be adjusted with a button outside of the baby carrier.
Which I find a bit inconvenient, especially if you have a fussy baby who can’t wait to get in the baby carrier and there you are, fumbling with buttons.
Both have padded adjustable shoulder straps, making it comfortable for wearers to use.
Both can only be used in an “H” style/ rucksack.
The Baby Bjorn has an adjustable head support or headrest with clip-in buckles, which is easier to operate, compared to Ergo Baby 360’s button adjustment.
Baby Bjorn’s headrest by the way, perfectly supports your newborn’s head while the Ergo 360 definitely needs an infant insert plus head support adjustment.
There are no prominent leg paddings for the Baby Bjorn but the Ergo 360 has a thick, structured leg padding to provide some comfort to your little one.
Both have a mixed review though, when it comes to the leg area of the baby carrier.
Some parents complained about their babies’ legs getting pinched or would have marks from both baby carriers.
Others find the mesh material uncomfortable for their babies.
Most are happy with both baby carriers so you really need to test out these products for a week or so, with your baby.
Both don’t have a small pouch or pocket.
Which I kinda find ridiculous, as a pocket would have been a must-have for baby wearers.
Interestingly though, some parents said that there are homemade pockets made for Ergo in Etsy so that’s quite brilliant!
You can check that homemade pocket here:
And here’s apparently, a universal pocket for different types of baby carriers, including a Baby Bjorn.
Both have pretty much simple yet classic colors and designs.
If you have a partner who’s not into colorful or flamboyant patterns, then they’d really appreciate wearing either a Baby Bjorn or Ergo 360.
Both are machine washable and because they’re both mesh, they can dry quicker than expected.
Just don’t use a fabric softener as that might affect the quality of the mesh material.
They are quite expensive baby carriers so you must really allot some budget for them.
Differences Between Baby Bjorn Vs Ergobaby
The Ergobaby is suitable for babies 4 months to 48 months (12 to 45 pounds), so that means you can use it longer, until toddlerhood!
The Baby Bjorn however, is used from newborns up to 3 years of age (8 lbs to 33 lbs), with no need for an infant insert.
No Infant Insert
There’s no need for an infant insert for the Baby Bjorn if you want to carry your newborn.
However, for the Ergo 360, you would need an infant insert to carry a newborn or a baby weighing from 7 lbs to 12 lbs.
The Baby Bjorn has 4 positions – newborn, facing in, facing out and back carry.
The Ergo 360 has also 4 – facing in, facing out, back and hip carry.
The Ergo 360 has a built-in lumbar support which is great for people who are prone to back and shoulder pains.
The Baby Bjorn One Air doesn’t have any lumbar support.
So that would mean most of the weight of your baby would go to your shoulder and back. Which can be painful, especially when wearing them for long periods of time.
Some parents though have no complaints over it and even find Baby Bjorn a more comfortable baby carrier.
You can nurse using the Ergobaby 360 baby carrier.
Just adjust and lower down the shoulder straps, to make space and make it comfortable for breastfeeding.
Nursing in a Babybjörn One Air might be a bit tricky though and they don’t really have that feature but some parents have managed to do it.
But they did say it was a bit harder, as compared to using an Ergo.
Ergo 360 comes with a built-in privacy hood that can be used for sun protection, breastfeeding, or for sleeping.
The Babybjörn One Air has no hood but I guess you can use the front flap as some sort of protection or sun cover.
The Ergo has an awesome ErgoPromise Lifetime Guarantee. It covers all baby carriers (including hip seats and wraps) manufactured in 2017 and after, and provides a limited warranty against manufacturing defects* in materials and workmanship for the lifetime* of the product.
The Baby Bjorn on the other hand, is kinda weird. I can’t seem to find specifically, its warranty online.
Seriously, just search for their warranty statement here and let me know if you find anything clear about how long is its warranty.
Compare Features of Baby Bjorn Vs Ergobaby
This is best viewed on a desktop. Check and compare the features of the Baby Bjorn Vs Ergobaby to find out which will suit your needs
|Features||Baby Bjorn One Air Mesh||Ergobaby 360 Mesh|
|Fit For All||Yes, can be worn by petite and plus size moms and tall and broad shouldered dads||Same|
|Comfort||Breathable, can be used during hot weather||Breathable, can be used during hot weather|
|Ease of Use||Moderately easy to slight hard||Moderately easy to slight hard|
|Seat Adjustment||2 height setting zippers||2 height setting buttons|
|Shoulder straps||Padded, adjustable, rucksack “H” style straps||Same|
|Design||Simple yet classic colours||Same|
|Weight/ Age||Newborns up to 3 years of age (8 to 33 lbs)||4 months to 48 months (12 to 45 lbs)|
|Infant Insert||No Need||Need, can be bought separately|
|Carrying Positions||4 – newborn, facing in, facing out and back carry||4 – facing in, facing out, back and hip carry|
Baby Bjorn Vs Ergobaby: Which is Better?
I’m usually a little bit reserved with my opinion on what seems to be the best product choice, as everything is subjective, but, in the battle of Baby Bjorn Vs Ergobaby (my POV), Ergo wins me over.
Not just because I’ve actually used one but because of what I find a priority in a baby carrier, that Ergo offers.
I find the Ergobaby a tad better than the Baby Bjorn as one can get a bit of mileage out of the Ergo as you can use it until toddlerhood or for a heavier baby. It also has lumbar support and it has a lifetime warranty. Those 3 features are mainly a priority for me when choosing a baby carrier.
Plus it has a privacy hood which is great to use, especially when it’s too bright and my baby wants to sleep.
That’s just me though.
The Baby Bjorn on the other hand, seems like an excellent choice if you don’t like using an infant insert for your baby.
Again, this is just my opinion so do check out both baby carriers personally and I highly recommend you try them out with your baby for a few weeks and see what really works for you.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider sharing it on Facebook or Twitter or pin it on your Pinterest. 🙂
- Ergobaby Embrace VS Omni 360: What’s The Difference? - April 14, 2021
- The Battle of Ergobaby 360 Vs Omni (Which One Is Better?) - April 14, 2021
- Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby: Which One Is Better? - March 31, 2021